A customer has filed a lawsuit against Best Buy after purchasing an open-box television labeled as "Excellent" condition for approximately $600, only to receive a broken set. The dispute over the faulty product and the retailer's refusal of return has reached court, with a judge allowing parts of the lawsuit to proceed.

On June 13, 2022, Sylvia Kemigisa bought an open-box television from Best Buy through their Open Box program. The TV arrived wrapped in plastic instead of its original packaging and displayed coloured lines rather than a picture, leading to it not working. Despite the defects, Best Buy allegedly refused to accept the return.

Best Buy's Open Box program offers previously returned products at discounted prices and categorizes them as "Excellent," "Satisfactory," or "Fair" based on their condition. The retailer describes items in "Excellent" condition as being brand-new with no physical flaws, scratches, or scuffs, including all original parts and accessories.

In response to the lawsuit, Best Buy claimed that the open-box TV had a cracked screen, which was not supported by Kemigisa and her nephew, Fesali Kaidi. They argued that the screen had never been cracked, labeling Best Buy's explanation as a lie. Best Buy's return policy allows customers to return products within 15 days of delivery if they are in like-new condition but may refuse returns for damaged items.

The court allowed Kemigisa to continue pursuing her claims based on either the packaging or the retailer's return policy, as Best Buy acknowledged a valid breach of contract claim. The judge also questioned Best Buy's alleged scheme through their Open Box program, selling defective products while misrepresenting their condition and subsequently refusing returns when customers discover issues with the products.