In a significant ruling that upholds the freedom of choice in matters of marriage, the Bombay High Court has granted relief to a 21-year-old Hindu woman who married a Muslim man and faced threats from her family. The court, comprising Justices Advait M Sethna and Ranjitsinha Raja Bhonsale, heard a criminal writ petition filed by the woman seeking protection to live with her husband. According to the petition, the woman had been in a relationship with the 21-year-old man for several years, and both families were aware of their union. They married on October 19, 2026, and sought police protection shortly after. However, the woman claimed that the Dharavi police refused to take action, and her parents allegedly took her against her will to Uttar Pradesh. Upon returning to Mumbai, she approached the High Court, expressing concerns about her safety and seeking protection to reside with her husband.
Advocate R K Mendadkar, representing the woman, argued that she was an adult capable of making decisions about her life. He referenced the Supreme Court's 2018 judgment in Shafin Jahan vs Asokan K M, which recognized the right to marry a person of one's choice as a fundamental part of the right to life and personal liberty under Article 21 of the Constitution. The High Court agreed with this legal position, stating that an adult woman has the complete liberty to exercise her choice and decide whom she wishes to marry without any force or pressure.
The petitioner's lawyer also raised concerns about the conduct of the police authorities. However, the bench declined to make specific observations on the allegations, emphasizing that the police must strictly adhere to the law in all matters. The court disposed of the plea without making any specific observations regarding the police's conduct at this stage.
