In a move that has sparked controversy, India has invited Pakistan to the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) Civilisational Dialogue Forum, scheduled for November 20 to 22 in New Delhi. This decision, however, has been met with criticism from the Congress party, who have accused the Modi government of welcoming the same country that sent terrorists to kill Indians. The Pakistani Climate Change and Environmental Coordination Minister, Musadik Masood Malik, a vocal critic of India over the Indus water standoff, has been nominated by Pakistan to attend the forum. Earlier this year, Malik had threatened to "cut off those hands" that tried to control Pakistan's waters, a statement that the Congress party pointed out in a post on X. The Congress accused the BJP of repeatedly displaying its "love for Pakistan," citing Prime Minister Narendra Modi's surprise visit to the neighboring country as an example. However, while some question India's policy towards Pakistan, others like Bengal minister and BJP leader Dilip Ghosh argue that Pakistan should improve its relations with India by giving up terrorism for its own benefit.
The decision to invite Pakistan comes at a time when the Indus Waters Treaty is in abeyance and bilateral ties are strained. India has consistently raised the issue of cross-border terrorism at the SCO, maintaining that the grouping must adopt a united approach against terrorism and its financing, without double standards. Accepting India's invite, Pakistan said the forum would bring together representatives from SCO member states to share views on cultural understanding and engagement among civilisations. Despite the controversy, Union Culture Minister Gajendra Singh Shekhawat expressed hope that Pakistan would attend the event.
The Congress party, however, remains concerned about unresolved issues with Pakistan, particularly cross-border terrorism. Congress MP Manish Tewari questioned what had changed since the Pahalgam terror attack and asked whether Pakistan had acted against the terrorist infrastructure operating within its borders. He said no such action had been taken. Former Foreign Minister and Congress leader Salman Khurshid expressed confusion over India's policy towards Pakistan, stating that the government's policy is never clear and asking for clarity in their position.
The invitation to Pakistan has sparked a heated debate in India, with some arguing that it is necessary to engage with Pakistan on various issues, while others maintain that Pakistan must take concrete steps to address cross-border terrorism before such engagements can be considered productive. The situation remains complex and unresolved as the SCO forum approaches.
