During an interaction at the University of Chicago, Congress leader and Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha, Rahul Gandhi, expressed his concerns over India's diminishing role in global diplomacy. He questioned why Pakistan was mediating talks between the United States and Iran while India remained on the sidelines. This critique came amidst External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar's remarks in March 2025, at an all-party meeting on the West Asia crisis, where he stated that India could not act as a "dalal nation" (broker nation) in global geopolitics.

Gandhi highlighted India's historically sophisticated understanding of geopolitics but lamented that the country was no longer actively involved in shaping global developments. He pointed to Pakistan's involvement in negotiations between Washington and Tehran as evidence of India's failure to translate its relationships with major world powers into diplomatic influence. Gandhi argued that personal friendships between political leaders could not determine the course of international relations, emphasizing the importance of understanding geopolitical developments and India's position in the world.

In addition, Gandhi criticized Prime Minister Narendra Modi's foreign policy, particularly its emphasis on personal relationships with global leaders, arguing that these friendships were insufficient to shape international relations. He clarified that he had no objection to leaders maintaining personal friendships but emphasized the importance of understanding geopolitical developments and India's position in the world. Gandhi also spoke about the changing global security architecture, arguing that the next global structure would involve several major powers and civilizations, with America, China, India, the Middle East, and Russia all having a role to play.

Finally, when asked about the possibility of India and Pakistan moving beyond mutual accusations and working together, Gandhi maintained that Pakistan must stop supporting and encouraging terrorism in India before any conversation could begin. He stated that it was impossible for India to engage in dialogue with Pakistan while innocent people continued to be killed.