A Texas appeals court has ordered a retrial in a contentious divorce case involving Kevin Lawrence Painter, Sr. and Tammy Renee Painter, after finding that the trial judge had signed the original decree without holding the promised final hearing. The Court of Appeals for the Sixth Appellate District of Texas at Texarkana overturned the judgment issued by the 62nd District Court of Franklin County in January 2026, stating that the lower court had misused its authority by granting the divorce and dividing the couple's property without hearing any testimony or receiving evidence to support the claims in Tammy Painter's petition. The disagreements between the parties regarding court procedures escalated in autumn 2025, with Kevin requesting disability accommodations and seeking to submit written evidence instead of attending in person due to serious medical conditions. However, these requests were denied, leading to missed hearings and a postponed trial. Despite promises of a second final hearing, the Franklin County court never announced or held one, instead issuing a final divorce decree that Kevin had neither agreed nor signed. The appeals court ruled that evidence is mandatory in such cases, and Kevin challenged the decree on five separate grounds, including concerns under the Americans with Disabilities Act and disputes over child custody and child support matters.

In the early stages of their marriage in 2010, Kevin and Tammy Painter had a child, identified as A.G.P., in Hopkins County in 2012. The family subsequently moved to Thailand in 2019, with Tammy returning to the United States six months later, while Kevin remained in Thailand to raise their minor child for the next six years. After several withdrawn divorce cases, Tammy filed the current case in Franklin County, leading to multiple motions from Kevin seeking special appearances, pauses, or delays in the proceedings, all of which were rejected by both the Franklin County trial court and higher appeals courts.

The final hearing scheduled for 20 November 2025 was postponed when Kevin was not present, with Tammy requesting a continuance while his case was still pending before the Texas Supreme Court. No witnesses or documents were presented during this hearing, and the trial judge signed a final divorce decree on 14 January 2026 without holding a second final hearing as promised. The written order stated that "[o]n November 20, 2025, the [trial court] heard this case," but Kevin had neither agreed to the document nor signed it. Kevin later asked the court to provide formal findings of fact, to which the trial court responded by repeating that the case "came on for trial before the [trial court] without a jury on November 20, 2025." The appeals court's ruling sends the case back to Franklin County for a new trial.