In a recent legal battle, the owners of Marilyn Monroe's former residence in Los Angeles have lost their fight against the city's preservation laws. Brinah Milstein and her husband, Roy Bank, sought permission to demolish the house, which they had purchased in 2023, to expand their adjacent estate. However, the city's historic-preservation process was initiated following public opposition to the proposed demolition, leading to the property being designated a historical-cultural monument in June 2024. The owners argued that the designation turned their private residence into a tourist nuisance, attracting unwanted attention from fans and causing security concerns. They claimed that the city had failed to adequately address these issues despite making the property a historic monument, and also alleged that they were left responsible for maintaining and protecting a residence with reduced economic value due to the restrictions. The federal lawsuit filed by Milstein and Bank centered on their claims of violated property rights under the Fifth Amendment. Despite their arguments, a federal judge dismissed their amended lawsuit in September 2026, ruling against their constitutional claims and allowing the historic designation protecting the property to remain in place.

The owners of the Spanish Colonial-style house where Hollywood icon Marilyn Monroe lived for six months before her death in 1962 have lost their legal battle against the city. Brinah Milstein and her husband, Roy Bank, purchased the property in 2023 with plans to demolish it and expand their adjacent estate. However, following public opposition to the proposed demolition, the city initiated its historic-preservation process in September 2023. The Los Angeles City Council unanimously approved the designation of the property as a historical-cultural monument in June 2024, protecting it from demolition or substantial alterations without the city's permission. Milstein and Bank argued that the designation turned their private residence into a tourist nuisance, attracting unwanted attention and causing security concerns. They also claimed that the restrictions had significantly reduced the property's economic value while forcing them to bear the financial burden of maintaining a historic monument. Despite these arguments, a federal judge dismissed their amended lawsuit in September 2026, ruling against their constitutional claims and allowing the historic designation to remain in place.

In a legal battle that pitted property rights against preserving Hollywood history, the owners of Marilyn Monroe's former home have lost their fight against the city. Brinah Milstein and her husband, Roy Bank, sought to demolish the house they purchased in 2023 to expand their adjacent estate. However, public opposition to the proposed demolition led to the property being designated a historical-cultural monument in June 2024. The owners argued that the designation turned their private residence into a tourist nuisance, attracting unwanted attention and causing security concerns. They also claimed that the restrictions had significantly reduced the property's economic value while forcing them to bear the financial burden of maintaining a historic monument. Despite these arguments, a federal judge dismissed their amended lawsuit in September 2026, ruling against their constitutional claims and allowing the historic designation protecting the property to remain in place. The decision ensures that Monroe's former home, which she purchased shortly before her death and spent the final months of her life in, will continue to stand as a testament to Hollywood history.