A California woman, Annaleine 'Anne' Reynolds, found herself embroiled in an unexpected legal dispute after discovering a fully built house worth around $500,000 on the vacant Hawaiian plot she had purchased for approximately $22,500 at a county tax auction in 2018. The property, located in Hawaiian Paradise Park, was part of a residential subdivision in Hawaii's Big Island. Reynolds, who was living in California during the Covid-19 pandemic, had not yet decided to travel to Hawaii and make use of the land. In 2023, she was informed by a real estate broker that he had sold a house built on her property without her knowledge or consent.
The house was part of a larger building project undertaken by Keaau Development Partnership, a local developer that had acquired several plots in Hawaiian Paradise Park. The company had engaged PJ's Construction to build around a dozen houses across the properties it owned in the subdivision. During this work, one of the houses was mistakenly constructed on Reynolds' land, which was not among the developer's purchased properties. This error led to disagreements among various parties involved, including the developer, building contractor, and professionals engaged in the construction process.
The dispute centered around who was responsible for the mistake and what should happen to a house that had been erected on privately owned land without permission. Reynolds declined the developer's offer of a comparable parcel of land as a resolution, arguing that it did not address the underlying issue of unauthorized construction on her property. The case took a significant turn in June 2024 when a Hawaii County judge ordered the removal of the house built on Reynolds' property, finding that the developer and construction company had assumed the risk of proceeding without a property survey. However, the court dismissed the developer's case against Reynolds and rejected its argument that her ownership title was invalid.
