In a significant decision that provides relief to international students studying in the United States, a district court in Massachusetts has temporarily blocked the implementation of restrictions on curricular practical training (CPT) that were introduced by the Trump administration. The order, issued on November 17, stays two policy broadcasts issued by the Student and Exchange Visitor Program (SEVP) in August 2020, pending a full review. The ruling also prohibits the government from implementing the broadcasts' interpretation of CPT requirements against the plaintiffs and their members, including employees and students.

The controversy stemmed from SEVP issuing broadcasts on August 12 and August 24, which narrowed eligibility for CPT. Under the revised interpretation, practical training would only qualify if it was mandatory for all students pursuing a specific degree program. This effectively excluded elective internships and training undertaken for academic credit, even where such opportunities were integral to a student's curriculum.

This change marked a departure from the federal government's longstanding position dating back to 1991, under which elective training undertaken for academic credit could qualify as CPT. The district court observed that the government had changed its interpretation without acknowledging or explaining the departure from its earlier position. It held that the plaintiffs were likely to succeed in their challenge arguing that the change was arbitrary and capricious under the Administrative Procedure Act.

Universities have been compelled to respond to the August broadcasts by withdrawing or denying CPT approvals, revising curricula, and altering career guidance for students. For instance, Columbia University denied CPT authorization to over 120 international students for the fall semester, while Grinnell College lost at least 13 internship opportunities for its students. Other universities like Cornell and Michigan State University have reportedly lost students due to these broadcasts.

The district court noted that some institutions have lost students because of the restrictions, while designated school officials (DSOs) face increased stress and apprehension about potential personal liability for approving training that could be viewed as non-compliant. The plaintiffs—which include the Association of American Universities, Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration, Association of Independent Colleges and Universities in Massachusetts, and NAFSA: Association of International Educators—argued that the policy change disrupted students' academic and career plans and imposed substantial costs on universities.

Granting interim relief, the court said the institutions had demonstrated irreparable harm, including expenditure of substantial resources to comply with the broadcasts and the threat of losing certification to enroll international students. The order stays the August 12 and August 24 broadcasts nationwide pending judicial review. Separately, the preliminary injunction prohibits the defendants from implementing or enforcing the new interpretation against the plaintiffs and their members, including students and employees, both prospectively and in relation to conduct and approvals predating the broadcasts.