A Michigan woman's appeal for a larger share of her former husband's wealth has been denied by the state's Court of Appeals. Cassandra Fameux argued that an equal division of assets would have given her nearly $1 million, but the court upheld the original 2018 agreement worth $705,000. The decision was made on November 16, 2026, dismissing Fameux's challenge to the property settlement.
The case involved Paul Gregory St Claire, an anesthesiologist who worked at the hospital where he and Fameux first met. Fameux claimed that the agreement was unfair because she was under court-appointed guardianship when she signed it. However, the appeals court found that a lawyer had been appointed by the court to protect her interests during the earlier case. The trial judge had also reviewed the agreement and deemed it fair.
St Claire and Fameux met in 2003 while working at the same hospital. They married in 2009 after having two children together. During their marriage, Fameux was admitted to psychiatric hospitals several times. In 2015, her sister was appointed as her legal guardian. St Claire filed a complaint for separate maintenance in 2017 while Fameux was still under guardianship. This allowed them to live apart and settle their financial matters without ending their marriage.
During the separate maintenance case, both spouses had their own lawyers. Attorney Melissa Leckie was appointed to represent Fameux's best interests under a September 2017 court order. The couple reached an agreement through mediation in 2018. Under the Judgment of Separate Maintenance (JOSM), Fameux received $130,000 in cash and another $575,000 was transferred into her retirement account. St Claire also agreed to pay spousal support that could be adjusted over a period of five years. All parties signed the agreement, with Fameux's sister initially intended to sign as her legal guardian but was later crossed out after lawyers agreed that Leckie had already been appointed to protect Fameux's interests. The trial court approved the agreement in December 2017, and Fameux later testified.
