A federal appeals court has given the green light for a group of homeowners in New Hampshire to continue their class-action trespass claim against Saint-Gobain Performance Plastics Corporation due to chemical contamination in their drinking water. However, the court rejected the class-action status for two related claims involving negligence and failure to warn, citing the need for individual property checks. The dispute stems from a manufacturing plant on the Merrimack River in Merrimack, New Hampshire, which has been producing chemical-resistant and weather-resistant fibreglass and films since the 1980s using perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA). Homeowners claim that PFOA particles escaped from the plant's exhaust stacks, contaminating the groundwater. The homeowners are seeking compensation for property devaluation, water replacement costs, cleanup expenses, and loss of enjoyment of their homes.

Contamination discovered in local water supplies:

Tests conducted by New Hampshire state officials in response to PFOA discovery in Saint-Gobain's Merrimack plant revealed contaminated levels of PFOA in both public and private water sources. In the public water district, PFOA levels ranged from undetectable to 141 parts per trillion (ppt), with around 45% of samples containing at least 20 ppt and 4% reaching or exceeding the state limit of 70 ppt. Private well tests showed higher levels, ranging from undetectable to 1,600 ppt, with about 70% of samples containing at least 20 ppt and 34% recording levels of 70 ppt or higher.

Negligence claims fail group test:

The homeowners initially filed their proposed class-action lawsuit in a New Hampshire state court in May 2016, but the case was moved to the US District Court for the District of New Hampshire. In December 2020, the plaintiffs asked the court to approve a class covering anyone who owned residential property on or after 4 March 2016 and had either a private well within a defined area or a home supplied by the Merrimack Village District Water Works. The New Hampshire Supreme Court ruled in 2023 that state law did not allow a separate claim for medical monitoring, leading to the removal of the medical-monitoring claim. In December 2023, US District Judge Joseph N. Laplante approved a class under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(b)(3) covering liability issues involving trespass, negligence, and negligent failure to warn. However, Saint-Gobain challenged this decision before the First Circuit, which disagreed with the lower court's decision to treat the negligence-related claims as group claims under New Hampshire law.