An electrical contractor based in Ohio, Jackson & Jackson, LLC, has been granted the opportunity to challenge county zoning regulations that restrict its business operations on a nine-acre property it purchased for $270,000. The Ohio Court of Appeals for the Twelfth District overturned part of an earlier ruling by the Butler County Court of Common Pleas on November 16, 2026, allowing Jackson & Jackson to proceed with two of its claims. The company intends to use the property's existing buildings and parking area for its electrical services business but was informed by county officials that commercial activities were not allowed due to the property's residential zoning rules.
The disputed property, located at 5670 West Alexandria Road in Madison Township, Butler County, Ohio, has a history of commercial and community use despite being situated in an R-1 Suburban Residence District. The site was previously used as a golf driving range, pizza shop, and church. Jackson & Jackson knew about the property's earlier commercial uses before completing the purchase and planned to utilize the land for part of its existing business after buying it in November 2021.
The dispute between Jackson & Jackson and Butler County officials began in May 2023 when the company was notified that it had violated zoning rules. The Butler County Zoning Inspector's office ordered the company to stop operating its business from the property, arguing that commercial activities, such as electrical contracting work, were not allowed under the R-1 residential zoning rules. Jackson & Jackson responded by applying for a use variance, but the Butler County Board of Zoning Appeals rejected the application in August 2023. The company did not challenge this decision through an administrative appeal at the Butler County Court of Common Pleas and continued operating its business from the property. Later in 2023, Zoning Inspector Dennis Dickard filed a lawsuit against Jackson & Jackson, asking the court to issue an injunction ordering the company to stop breaking the county's zoning rules. The company filed a response and a counterclaim against the county, arguing that the county's restrictions were unconstitutional when applied to its property.
In their amended counterclaim, Jackson & Jackson argued that the zoning rules amounted to an illegal taking of private property without compensation, citing the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments to the US Constitution. The appeals court has restored two of the company's claims, allowing them to continue with arguments related to the constitutionality of the zoning restrictions. However, a third claim challenging the restrictions remains dismissed. The case is set to return to the lower court for further proceedings.
