In a significant decision on November 17, 2026, the Texas Fourteenth Court of Appeals halted a DNA test ordered by a lower court in a probate dispute over a handwritten will. The case involves the estate of John Demel, who left his property and possessions to Roxanne Bourdon and Chris Quijada, but his first cousin once removed, Peter K. Demel, challenged the document's validity. The appeals court ruled that the probate court erred in ordering Peter to provide DNA samples before deciding on the will's authenticity. Consequently, Peter cannot be compelled to undergo genetic testing as per the existing order, and the probate court was instructed to cancel its directive requiring him to take the test.

The handwritten will, or holographic will, named Bourdon and Quijada as beneficiaries of John's estate after his death. Neither beneficiary was a legal heir by blood or marriage, but John clearly stated in the document that he wanted both individuals to inherit his property and possessions. Chris Quijada filed an application with Harris County Probate Court No. 5 to have the will accepted for probate and requested letters testamentary, which would grant him legal control over the estate. However, Peter Demel entered the case by opposing Quijada's application and challenging the handwritten will.

The probate court initially rejected Quijada's request for DNA testing, stating that it lacked the power to order such a test under Texas law. But after another hearing, the court changed its decision and approved Quijada's request for genetic testing. Peter objected to this order and appealed to the Texas Fourteenth Court of Appeals, arguing that the probate judge had exceeded their legal authority in ordering him to undergo DNA testing. The appeals court agreed with Peter, stating that the lower court did not have the power to order genetic testing while the will dispute remained unresolved.