The Trump administration's plans to use Pakistan as a transit hub for deporting Iranian and Afghan immigrants have raised concerns, with human rights groups warning that the move could expose vulnerable asylum seekers to persecution. Court filings reveal discussions about routing deportation flights through Islamabad, while lawyers claim some Iranian detainees were even issued Pakistani transit visas. The controversy deepened after two attempts to deport Iranians were aborted, including a flight on November 10 that reportedly had to turn back due to Pakistan's refusal to receive the passengers. While Pakistan has acknowledged discussions with Washington over a proposal, it maintains no agreement was finalized. Critics fear that Pakistan could become a conduit for sending people to Iran and Taliban-controlled Afghanistan.

Furthermore, US lawmakers, immigration lawyers, and Afghan advocates have expressed concern about the potential use of Pakistan as an intermediary in deportations. They warn of possible sanctions if Pakistani officials knowingly facilitate deportations that put vulnerable Afghans at risk under Taliban rule. The controversy arises amidst President Trump's mass-deportation drive, which relies heavily on third countries to facilitate removals due to the lack of formal diplomatic relations with Iran and Afghanistan's Taliban government.

The latest controversy was triggered by an ICE deportation flight carrying Iranian nationals that took off from Mesa, Arizona, only to turn back and land at the same airport 30 minutes later. According to reports, Pakistan declined to receive the deportees, forcing the aircraft to return. The Trump administration's plans to use Pakistan as a transit point for US deportations had been in the works for weeks. On October 31, court documents showed plans to fly detained Afghan nationals from Louisiana to Pakistan before transferring them to Afghanistan.

The proposed operation drew criticism due to concerns about the safety of former US military allies and individuals fearing persecution under the Taliban. The controversy comes after a court halted the Trump administration's plan to deport around 150 to 200 Afghan nationals through Pakistan on November 3. The proposed operation would have flown them from the US to Pakistan before transferring them to Taliban-controlled Afghanistan.